Skip to content

Which Health Insurer grew leads 2000% in 12 months, on a conversion rate that rose from 5% to over 20%.

Which Health Insurer sends high-intent health insurance leads straight into its brokers' dialling systems.

Winner, Innovative Agency of the Year UK Agency Awards 2026

Trusted by

  • Clarks
  • Hyatt
  • Missoma
  • Natural History Museum
  • Hilti
  • Finisterre

The results

Month 1 to month 12 of the campaign.

  • +2000%Leads, month 1 to month 12Which Health Insurer
  • Over 20%from 5%On-site conversion rate over a yearWhich Health Insurer
  • -20%Cost per acquisition, despite far higher volumeWhich Health Insurer
Two landing page variants, A and B, for a private health insurance comparison, shown side by side

The challenge.

Which Health Insurer needed a large number of leads at a £50 cost per acquisition within the first three months. Its brokers run big sales teams that need a steady live supply, so volume mattered, but so did intent and policy size.

The market is expensive. Clicks sometimes cost £20, which meant the landing page had to keep converting better just to hold the cost down. The leads also had to come from people shopping for a proper health insurance premium, not a low-cost cash plan, a dental plan or travel cover.

Client
Which Health Insurer
Sector
Health insurance lead generation
Work
Paid search and conversion rate optimisation

What PUSH did.

PUSH started with the search account. Keyword research across three or four tools, including Google's own, Neil Patel and SEMrush, produced a tight but large keyword list, plus more than 1,000 negative keywords to cut irrelevant searches. Broad match and dynamic search campaigns ran on a lower budget alongside the main campaigns, as exploratory campaigns that showed how the market was moving and which new keywords to add or block. An audience of people recently researching travel outside the EU was used to keep travel enquiries out.

The second job was conversion rate. For more than a year, at least one A/B test was running on the landing pages every month, from button colours to completely different form layouts. Tests that lost were caught quickly, paused and replaced with the old version, which kept the page improving month on month.

Book a call about your account. Tell us your numbers and your goal.

We will say where we would start.

Results differ by account. The stories above are what happened for those clients.

A PUSH speaker presenting a chart of technology waves, from steam power to AI, to an audience in a lounge venue